Underground Pizza in New York City

Underground Pizza in New York City
4.5 / 5
49 reviews

3 Hanover Sq New York, NY 10004, New York City

Overview

Restaurant Hours

Monday

9:00 am - 9:00 pm

Tuesday

9:00 am - 9:00 pm

Wednesday

9:00 am - 9:00 pm

Thursday

9:00 am - 9:00 pm

Friday

9:00 am - 9:00 pm

Saturday

10:30 am - 7:00 pm

Sunday

Closed

Menu

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Underground Pizza
CM
Carrie Marvin
google
11.28.2020
5/5

My son had a delicious gluten free pizza. Nice sauce! I had a slice and it was tasty! The owner is super friendly and welcoming. Come check it out if you are in the area. They also have pastas and hot grinders/subs.

Underground Pizza
RP
Rob Paris
google
09.15.2018
4/5

Good pizza that's been around for a long time. Good for slices or a full pie.

Underground Pizza
DT
Dara Taylor
google
09.11.2018
4/5

They were able to do vegan, but wish they had vegan cheese!! Still yum and friendly staff :)

Underground Pizza
RK
Ran Kam
google
08.12.2018
4/5

Great prices. Good selection of pizza.

Underground Pizza
DK
Deano Kramer
google
05.21.2018
5/5

First time to New York and heard good reviews about Underground Pizza. It was my first experience of a big New York slice. I ordered two full pizza's during my time in New York and loved both of them.

Underground Pizza
AR
Alex Ranes
google
05.17.2018
5/5

Awesome thin crust pizza and not too expensive

Underground Pizza
BS
Bradley Scott
google
05.10.2018
5/5

Consistently excellent every time! The guys behind the counter are always smiling and patient as you pick what you want. Hard to not want everything! Best crust in lower Manhattan!

Underground Pizza
mk
mahyar kamalinafar
google
03.07.2018
5/5

Great pizza at affordable prices. Awesome for out of towners.

Underground Pizza
VG
Valencia G
google
03.01.2018
3/5

Pizza is good! But the staff there are extremely demotivated, lazy and unfriendly unfortunately.

Underground Pizza
JA
Jeff Adkins
google
02.20.2018
4/5

Really good pizza. Friendly staff. Made the pizza custom. Good prices for NYC

Underground Pizza
TL
Tobias Lindberg
google
02.14.2018
5/5

Awesome pizza! I loved the pizza I got here, wish I could visit it again!

Underground Pizza
JS
Jaspreet Singh
google
02.11.2018
3/5

I took pepperoni Pizza slice. It was tasty but the edges were too hard too eat. That spoiled the overall experience. In lunch hours, there is always heavy footfall of take-out customers. The service is quick, you won't have to wait much once you place your order.

Underground Pizza
MJ
Mishal J. Kamdar
google
01.02.2018
4/5

Really nice pizza. And fairly priced.

Underground Pizza
SV
Sri Velagapudi
google
11.15.2017
5/5

Amazing food, Buffalo Chicken pizza is one of the best around this area. Very quick order time even during rush hour.

Underground Pizza
JJ
Joseph Januszkiewicz
google
10.25.2017
3/5

A decent NY style slice, but not the best. A bit expensive for what it is. Friendly staff.

Underground Pizza
AW
Austin Walker
google
09.24.2017
5/5

If you live in the FiDi, this is probably one of your favorite pizza places. I have been probably 10 times in the past ten or so weeks, and absolutely love the pizza and service. Get a slice of "Grandma" pizza if they have it available!

Underground Pizza
AR
Andrew Rodenhouse
google
09.22.2017
5/5

Great pizza and fast service.

Underground Pizza
EB
Echo Bubb
google
09.12.2017
5/5

I'm not one to seek out thin crust pizza, but it's NYC! Absolutely delicious. Little wait time. Big slice, worth the money. Served nice and hot. Dinning room is up a set of stairs. Glad I found this place!

Underground Pizza
MH
Michael Hirschhorn
google
09.09.2017
5/5

I love this pizza!! My favorite is the grandma pie. It’s so fresh and delicious every time. Owner has been doing it 38 years. I’d trust him with my life.

Underground Pizza
RY
RAIDER YD
google
09.05.2017
5/5

By far some of the best pizza I've ever had! Recommend this to everybody who ever visits New York!

Underground Pizza
Enixa
google
08.27.2017
5/5

Went for lunch using the mealpal app. Pizza is always good. Friendly customer services.

Underground Pizza
AR
Amy Recinos
google
07.13.2017
5/5

When we arrived at Battery Park, NY I set a pizza restaurant search and saw the great ratings for Underground Pizza and recommended my family and I eat there. There’s a lot of construction off Broadway right now, so the Yelp map directions threw us off, but we ended up passing the New York Stock Exchange building and enjoyed a few nice buildings along the way. Once we arrived we were immediately greeted by one of the servers and given the chance to order. We were pretty hungry so we ordered 5 different slices of pizza to try a little of everything and share. We asked if they could cut the slices in thirds and they said, “Of course”! The pizza wasn’t greasy and every slice we had hit the spot! Then to our surprise the owner, Ben, introduced himself and gave us a great story about how Underground Pizza came to be. Great local spot, with great service and staff! Will definitely be back on my next trip to New York. Cheers!

Underground Pizza
MP
Manuel Pedraza
google
05.04.2017
5/5

The Buffalo Chicken pizza is one of the best pizzas I've had in my life. Lovely restaurant

Underground Pizza
AJ
Arjun Jarvis
google
05.02.2017
5/5

Very well kept and welcoming restaurant. They offer large portions and for fair rates. I liked the meals very much and the staff members were very friendly and chatty. Will definitely recommend this restaurant.

Underground Pizza
TH
T Ha
google
03.17.2017
5/5

Gluten-free pizza was really great. Friendly service. Good stuff.

Underground Pizza
AT
Allen Todd
google
03.05.2017
3/5

I had the calzone which arrived quickly. The calzone was tasty, the only had plastic utensils which made eating difficult. My wife had a slice of pizza, but was not impressed.

Underground Pizza
CN
Ceena Nafarzadegan
google
02.24.2017
5/5

Excellent margherita pizza

Underground Pizza
JV
John Vinueza
google
02.21.2017
5/5

My favorite pizza in the area, at good prices. We also regularly order pies from them, and they are always consistently delicious. Good stuff, guys!

Underground Pizza
KG
Karlie Garcia
google
01.22.2017
5/5

Delicious pizza, reasonably priced, and room th o sit down inside. We had a half pepperoni/half sausage pie and it was enough food for 2 adults and 5 children.

Underground Pizza
BS
Ben S
google
01.19.2017
5/5

Nice mellow place with quick service and good pizza; slices are also rather large. Would definitely come back when I am downtown again.

Underground Pizza
RG
Robin Gowin
google
01.04.2017
5/5

Good place for pizza and other Italian food dishes. Pretty quick service during lunch hours

Underground Pizza
mv
maxim vincent
google
11.24.2016
5/5

Awesome place for a quick bite! The pizza and chicken pasta with broccoli were delicious.

Underground Pizza
Andrea
google
10.23.2016
4/5

Very good, freshly made pasta, very nice staff, great prices and portions, plus there's seating available in the back.

Underground Pizza
LJ
Lindsey Jaroszek
google
10.13.2016
5/5

Great service, delicious pizza and a good place to get a little grub to continue your trip to NYC. I recommend their food.

Underground Pizza
FA
Frank Auriemma
google
10.08.2016
1/5

Not good pizza, and crazy over priced at $5 per slice for a square.

Underground Pizza
SF
Sandra Ferrari
google
10.03.2016
5/5

We always order from there at work. Went there on my own, enjoyed a delicious 🍕 and the place looks small but go up the stairs, you will find seats. Pretty awesome if you don't want to go 😁 back to work and eat peacefully.

Underground Pizza
AN
Alex Niederman
google
09.05.2016
4/5

Great slice spot, perfect for lunch, very fast. Highly recommend the square spinach slice. It's basically like spinch dip on pizza.

Underground Pizza
AR
Ayyappa Ramakrishna
google
08.27.2016
3/5

The pizzas are good enough on any given day. Cards are accepted for a single slice. Mushroom and cheese are the most preferred ones. Old place with electric ovens.

Underground Pizza
CK
Cathy Ko
google
08.05.2016
5/5

Their pizza is amazingly good!!! The price is acceptable and the taste is awesome! My friend even ate two pieces. The staff are nice. We will definitely visit again.

Underground Pizza
KC
Kenneth Combs
google
07.18.2016
1/5

$5 for the smallest slice of Pepperoni pizza I've ever seen in New York, and it isn't even that good. I'd avoid it If I were you, more affordable option RIGHT around the corner.

Underground Pizza
EH
Evangeline Heater
google
06.04.2016
5/5

It took 15 minutes just to get our drinks, but pizza was delicious, I just wish we got better service.

Underground Pizza
AR
Andres Racines
google
06.02.2016
5/5

Good pizza for a quick lunch

Underground Pizza
CT
CIRCUIT TREE
google
04.20.2016
5/5

I was pleasantly surprised to find another nyc pizza place that has a really great slice and this place is it. I have just added one more to my collection of pizza spots.

Underground Pizza
JB
Jim Bernatek
google
04.05.2016
4/5

No e place to grab a slice down near wall street.

Underground Pizza
GS
Greg Swaim
google
03.23.2016
5/5

If you're looking for great pizza at a good price, spend your money here! Very friendly staff as well (including the owner). Visiting from NC.

Underground Pizza
ET
Ezra The Derpy Derp Melon
google
02.22.2016
5/5

A classic New York slice but nothing to write home about. Their specialty (spinach, Detroit style, etc.) pizza is particularly good. All service and food was cheap and fast and the staff were great!

Underground Pizza
OE
Ofer Eini
google
01.23.2016
5/5

Nice and fast, ate a whole pizza by myself it's just so tasty!

Underground Pizza
PC
Paul Cintolo
google
01.18.2016
4/5

Very chill and the entire staff included a very nice group of people. The pizza was delicious, quick, and they had a great selection of slices that were ready. I ate their two days in a row and a great benefit is that they heat your slices so that they are hot and not just warm. I'll revisit for sure during my next trip!

Underground Pizza
LL
Lelah Lilly
google
01.17.2016
5/5

The good pizza lunch and dinner is great thanks for your recommendation always and the crew great job. i recommend this place great food and environment. I love it!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12124254442

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!